I Found This Funny My Favorite Pieces of Humor and Some That May Not Be Funny at All
See a Problem?
Thanks for telling us about the problem.
Friend Reviews
Community Reviews
You've certainly got a deliciously dark side to you, don't you? Tell your critics who complain that your title is deceiving that perhaps they should actually read the entire title, especially the ...and Some That May Not Be Funny At All part. However, considering you're one of the men behind some of the laugh-out-loud movies of our day, just putting your name on the book would probably be considered "deceiving" and "false advertising."
That being said, I think your book probably could h
Dear Judd,You've certainly got a deliciously dark side to you, don't you? Tell your critics who complain that your title is deceiving that perhaps they should actually read the entire title, especially the ...and Some That May Not Be Funny At All part. However, considering you're one of the men behind some of the laugh-out-loud movies of our day, just putting your name on the book would probably be considered "deceiving" and "false advertising."
That being said, I think your book probably could have done with some more editing. I loved a few of the stories, and really didn't care for some of them (most notably most of the Funny stories). For almost 500 pages of short stories that I did overall like, there were quite a few that seemed to meander in unnecessary places - short stories that didn't fit like the rest of them.
My Favorite Parts?
A Mother's Tale, by James Agee: Hell, there's even a warning in your introduction:
And skip James Agee until you can handle the hard stuff
Even though I knew exactly where this story was going from the first few lines, sometimes it's nice to read a story that reacts and flows in just the way that you expect it to. I'm not saying it was boring, but that it went in such a way that stories as such go. It was certainly not funny, and I can see how you consider it "the hard stuff," but for people that have been reading for as long as I have, the issues addressed have all already been addressed. It felt like I'd already read the story before - again, not in a boring way - in a comforting, homecoming sort of way (for all its disturbing aspects).
I Demand To Know Where You're Taking Me, by Dan Chaon: I was honestly surprised that this was written by a man. I felt as though everything going on in the mind of the main character (mother/wife/sister-in-law) was true. I'm not saying that men can't write women, but that I can usually tell the difference, and this felt more like it was written by a mother. Again, this was perhaps one of the more disturbing stories. With the main character's brother-in-law in prison, and his stuff being stored indefinitely at her house, she and her family have also inherited his pet bird. The foul mouthed bird with an attitude becomes her nemesis and a catch all for all her bad feelings towards her husband and her brother-in-law. The story ends with a strong finality that so many short stories seem to be missing.
Selected Drawings, by Hugleikur Dagsson: Now see, these had me rolling. I have a very dry sense of humor, and frankly, Judd, most of your movies are not my cup of tea, but these comics? Fucking Hilarious.
Six Selected Pieces, by Simon Rich: With stories a page or less in length, these all packed a powerful punch. They were funny, but they weren't crass.
Overall, Good book, but dear Gods, did it really need to have so many stories? Sometimes, less is more.
...more
That said, most of the selections were strong, once one picks up on the tone, which is not haha funny in most cases.
...more
Another however, the rest of the book is a great collection of funny writing. Just get through that first third. Or skip it, what do I care? Do what you want and leave me out of it.
Interesting, at times, but not funny.
LOVED the pieces about Freaks & Geeks, and about Bill Hicks.
From the introduction, by Apatow:
"Becoming even semiliterate had an immediate effect on my writing. The courage to dig deep and reveal inspired me to take chances and look at parts of myself I had tried to avoid through workaholism and masturbation." p. 9
"And if you are reading this on an iPad, you are a douchebag." p. 11
From "Ocean Avenue" by Michael Chabon
"If you can still see how you could have once loved a person, you are still in love; an extinct love is always wholly incredible." p. 81
From "And Now a Word from the Booth..." by Paul Feig
On sports: "I don't begrudge anybody for getting excited about the fortunes of the team they've decided to follow. It's just when it really seems to affect their happiness and satisfaction with their lives that it makes me nervous." p. 155-156
From "Jason the Real" by Tony Hoagland
"It is so human to turn a freedom into pain
and it is so sweet when life
comes to teach you suffering" p. 215-216
From "Majesty" by Miranda July
"This pain, this dying, this is just normal. This is how life is. In fact, I realize, there never was an earthquake. Life is just this way, broken, and I am crazy to hope for something else." p. 233
From "The Goat Boy Rises" by John Lahr (this is the piece about Bill Hicks)
"'To me, the comic is the guy who says 'Wait a minute' as the consensus forms,' Hicks told me as we climbed the stairs to his dressing room. 'He's the antithesis of the mob mentality. The comic is a flame - like Shiva the Destroyer, toppling idols no matter what they are. He keeps cutting everything back to the moment.'" p. 236
"Most TV comics trade in brand-name jokes or jokes that play off physical stereotypes. They don't question their culture so much as pander to its insatiable hunger for distraction." p. 241
From "Good Country People" by Flannery O'Connor (I remember reading her work in high school, too - twisted stuff!)
"She looked at nice young men as if she could smell their stupidity." p. 316
"True genius can get an idea across even to an inferior mind." p. 324
From "Hard Rain" by Tony Hoagland
"Even serenity can become something horrible
if you make a commercial about it
using smiling, white-haired people
quoting Thoreau to sell retirement homes
in the Everglades, where the swamp has been
drained and bulldozed into a nineteen-hole golf course
with electrified alligator barriers." p. 429
I appreciate that all Apatow's proceeds from this book go to what sounds to be a very worthwhile charity promoting writing, so I will choose to forgive it. The book is maybe 1/3 humor (which I typically didn't find all that funny - lots of filler cartoons and one entire sitcom screenplay) and 2/3 short stories that Apatow likes...and that would be OK if most of them hadn't been lifted from a book called You've Got to Read This which I had already read (the book is, I believe, wri
My copy is ARC.I appreciate that all Apatow's proceeds from this book go to what sounds to be a very worthwhile charity promoting writing, so I will choose to forgive it. The book is maybe 1/3 humor (which I typically didn't find all that funny - lots of filler cartoons and one entire sitcom screenplay) and 2/3 short stories that Apatow likes...and that would be OK if most of them hadn't been lifted from a book called You've Got to Read This which I had already read (the book is, I believe, writers writing about their favorite short stories, and then the stories). Apatow is up front about that in his introduction, and also tells readers there is going to be a lot less humor than they might of thought, so there's that.
Anyway, as with most collections, a mixed bag. Most of the non-humor pieces are fairly famous short stories, including the heartbreaking "A Mother's Tale" which I refuse to ever let sear my eyeballs and heart again. It was nice to revisit a favorite O'Connor and to read an Alice Munro that I don't recall having read before. However, with all the retreads and the unfunny humor, it wasn't the book I was looking for right before surgery (um, thanks for cheering me up with multiple stories involving dead animals?!) and wasn't worth the time for me. However, if you don't read a lot of short stories and want to support a worthy cause by purchasing a copy, knock yourself out.
...more
Important to note is that many of the stories are just good stories, and have little to do with an overarching comic theme. Too often we mistake books/collections on comedy to stay in the comic, but this collection explores the relation between the comic and non-comic.
Stories of note:
The stories of comedy insight, Apatow's diary o
If you enjoy collections of short stories as well as contemporary comedic voices such as Conan O'Brian, Jon Stewart, and Bill Hicks, then this is a good read for you.Important to note is that many of the stories are just good stories, and have little to do with an overarching comic theme. Too often we mistake books/collections on comedy to stay in the comic, but this collection explores the relation between the comic and non-comic.
Stories of note:
The stories of comedy insight, Apatow's diary on Freaks and Geeks, or the brief bio-sketch on Bill Hicks, were interesting and fun, but mostly surface level. They were great stories, but they do not typify the central character of the collection.
Personal Stories, like the one about the single woman trying to date or the one about Paul Fieg's football announcing experiences were interesting.
The comic strips and scripts were interesting.
But the best asset to the collection are the stories from Hemingway, Fitzgerald, and O'Conner. After the O'Conner piece I gasped aloud and had to take a break, because the end of the story was just so incredible.
Anyway, I do recommend this book if you are looking for laughter and something more.
...more
(There is a spoiler of one of the stories below..)
There's no doubt that the works are fascinating and emotional, and it certainly is an interesting and wide-ranging collection, but after finishing Dan Chaon's "I demand to know where you're taking me" about a wife who's
(There is a spoiler of one of the stories below..)
There's no doubt that the works are fascinating and emotional, and it certainly is an interesting and wide-ranging collection, but after finishing Dan Chaon's "I demand to know where you're taking me" about a wife who's marriage is falling apart due to her brother in law being a convicted rapist and having to take care of his twisted parrot who ends up being beaten to death at the end... not funny! Just like the ten stories before this. And I seem to find humor in just about everything. I just about put down the book right there, sick to my stomach in a definitely not-funny way. Though Apatow may have found my response funny. So there you go.
I'm grateful to this book for including some authors
It's marketed as a humor anthology, but the selections are mostly appalling or depressing. I know he warned me in the second half of the title, but wow! There are a few gems in among the icky stuff, e.g. Ian Frazier's "Coyote v. Acme" and Jonathan Franzen's reminiscence of his relationship with Charles Schulz's "Peanuts" through Franzen's childhood, plus works by Philip Roth and Flannery O'Connor that have appeared in better company elsewhere.I'm grateful to this book for including some authors I'd heard of and wondered if they were worth checking out ... bye-bye, Miranda July!
Just let me say this: if you find Hugleikur Dagsson's stick-figure cartoons marvelously witty, you and I are not from the same planet.
...more
Despite the title of this book & reputation of the famed editor there's little humor compiled but there is however some terrific fiction from Raymond Carver, Andre Dubus & Tobias Wolf and there's some great non-fiction from Paul Feig, Jonathan Franzen, Steven Martin and a profile of Bill Hicks from the New Yorker magazine.
The best "funny" piece just might be the hilar
This might be the only collection where writing from Adam Sandler is in the same anthology with fiction from F Scott Fitzgerald.Despite the title of this book & reputation of the famed editor there's little humor compiled but there is however some terrific fiction from Raymond Carver, Andre Dubus & Tobias Wolf and there's some great non-fiction from Paul Feig, Jonathan Franzen, Steven Martin and a profile of Bill Hicks from the New Yorker magazine.
The best "funny" piece just might be the hilarious tv pilot "Lookwell" with Adam West and written by Conan O'Brien & Robert Smigel. Only 1 episode of the show was ever produced & its available to watch on YouTube.
...more 
Related Articles
Welcome back. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account.
Source: https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/8482884
0 Response to "I Found This Funny My Favorite Pieces of Humor and Some That May Not Be Funny at All"
Postar um comentário